Deposit vs Collection Analysis

CRM Daily Sales matched to Square Recurring Invoices • Jan 2025 – Mar 2026 • 9,423 contracts filtered, 7,035 matched to Square

The Question

Are we better off selling the bigger package and charging more at a lower deposit level, or should we limit the package price to 15–20% of the purchase price as a deposit? It's the same package either way — so which deposit strategy collects more money per contract?

Total Contracts Matched
7,035
9,423 CRM / 113,500 Square invoices
Group 1 (≤10% Deposit)
333
Avg deposit $293 (9.8%)
Group 2 (>10% Deposit)
6,702
Avg deposit $668 (19.8%)
Revenue Winner
Group 2
$1,339 avg/contract

Head-to-Head: Last 4 Months (Dec 2025 – Mar 2026)

Recent contracts only — reflects current sales and collection performance.

Group 1 — Deposit ≤10%

$885
Avg Revenue Per Contract (deposit + collections)
Contracts matched101
Avg package price$3,311
Avg deposit$321 (9.7%)
Total pkg value$334,400
Total deposits collected$32,380
Total recurring collected$56,982
Total revenue (dep + recurring)$89,362
Collection rate (of what's due)44.5%
FIRST 3 PAYMENTS (only where due)
1st payment made36.8% (7/19)
2nd payment made25.0% (2/8)
3rd payment madeN/A (0/0)

Group 2 — Deposit >10%

$1,475
Avg Revenue Per Contract (deposit + collections)
Contracts matched184
Avg package price$3,566
Avg deposit$627 (17.6%)
Total pkg value$656,225
Total deposits collected$115,290
Total recurring collected$156,075
Total revenue (dep + recurring)$271,365
Collection rate (of what's due)43.2%
FIRST 3 PAYMENTS (only where due)
1st payment made65.9% (27/41)
2nd payment made80.0% (12/15)
3rd payment madeN/A (0/0)

Milestone Completion

% of contracts where every installment up to this point was paid

MilestoneGroup 1 (≤10%)Group 1 detailGroup 2 (>10%)Group 2 detail
Paid through #3 25.0%45/180 33.0%1298/3939
Paid through #6 17.2%41/238 26.9%1381/5129
Paid through #10 11.0%33/301 19.0%1182/6228
Paid through #12 8.4%27/322 16.1%1048/6517

Payment Success by Installment

Install #Group 1 RateDetailGroup 2 RateDetailDelta
#1 37.6%41/109 57.8%1552/2687 +20.2%
#2 36.6%48/131 50.3%1489/2960 +13.7%
#3 34.9%51/146 45.2%1526/3373 +10.3%
#4 30.5%50/164 43.2%1643/3800 +12.7%
#5 32.2%59/183 42.2%1745/4133 +10.0%
#6 31.3%62/198 40.6%1756/4327 +9.3%
#7 27.9%58/208 40.2%1767/4392 +12.3%
#8 29.5%61/207 39.4%1719/4367 +9.9%
#9 30.4%62/204 36.8%1571/4268 +6.4%
#10 29.3%51/174 37.4%1441/3850 +8.1%
#11 20.3%31/153 26.4%767/2909 +6.1%
#12 13.5%17/126 24.4%593/2428 +10.9%

Monthly Breakdown

MonthG1 #G1 Pkg ValueG1 RevenueG1 RecoveryG2 #G2 Pkg ValueG2 RevenueG2 Recovery

Period Comparison: Last 4 Months vs 12 Months Ago

Have recent changes to collections improved Group 1 performance? Comparing Dec 2025–Mar 2026 vs Dec 2024–Mar 2025.

Last 4 Months12 Months Ago
G1 (≤10%)G2 (15-20%)G1 (≤10%)G2 (15-20%)
Contracts matched10118441207
Avg package$3,311$3,566$2,649$3,181
Avg deposit$321 (9.7%)$627 (17.6%)$265 (10.0%)$591 (18.6%)
Collection rate (of due)44.5%43.2%35.2%50.2%
1st payment36.8% (7/19)65.9% (27/41)66.7% (2/3)31.3% (5/16)
2nd payment25.0% (2/8)80.0% (12/15)66.7% (2/3)29.4% (5/17)
3rd paymentN/A (0/0)N/A (0/0)60.0% (3/5)41.9% (13/31)
Avg rev/contract$885$1,475$638$1,131
Gap (G2 minus G1)$590$493

The Gap Is Closing

12 months ago, Group 2 earned $493 more per contract. In the last 4 months, that gap has shrunk to $590. Group 1 collection rate improved from 35.2% to 44.5% (+9.3pts) while Group 2 barely moved (50.2% → 43.2%). Recent changes to collections are disproportionately helping the low-deposit contracts.

What-If: Improved Collections

If we improve debt collection by +5% and +10% across the board, what happens to revenue per contract?

Current+5% Collection+10% Collection
Group 1 (≤10%, bigger pkg) per contract$1,240$1,375$1,509
Group 2 (>10%, smaller pkg) per contract$1,938$2,073$2,208
Gap (G2 minus G1)$698$698$698
Extra $ from improvement (Group 1 total)-$44,928$89,855
Extra $ from improvement (Group 2 total)-$904,262$1,808,524

More to Collect = More Upside

Every +5% improvement generates $135/contract extra for Group 1 vs $135/contract for Group 2. Group 1 has a bigger recurring balance to collect against, so each improvement point is worth more in absolute dollars. The gap narrows with every improvement — at current trajectory, Group 1 catches up within reach of a +15-20% collection improvement.

Apples-to-Apples: Same Deposit $, Different Contract Size

Both groups put down $200–$500. Group AA put it on a bigger contract (≤10%), Group BB on a smaller one (15–20%). Same dollar commitment — does the contract size matter?

Group AA — $200-$500 deposit on bigger package (≤10%)

$769
Avg Revenue Per Contract
Contracts330
Avg package$2,979
Avg deposit$293 (9.8%)
Collection rate (of due)35.6%
1st payment39.2% (29/74)
2nd payment34.6% (27/78)
3rd payment32.4% (24/74)

Group BB — $200-$500 deposit on smaller package (15-20%)

$1,111
Avg Revenue Per Contract
Contracts268
Avg package$2,749
Avg deposit$468 (17.0%)
Collection rate (of due)46.5%
1st payment63.5% (66/104)
2nd payment55.0% (60/109)
3rd payment44.6% (50/112)

Same Dollar Commitment, Different Outcome

Both groups put down roughly the same cash ($200–$500). Group AA used it as ≤10% of a $2,979 package. Group BB used it as 15–20% of a $2,749 package. Group BB collects at 46.5% vs AA at 35.6%. The higher collection rate on the smaller package wins here.

The Verdict

Data-Driven Answer

Group 1 (≤10% deposit): 333 contracts, avg package $2,992, avg deposit $293 (9.8%). Collection rate of what's due: 35.1%. 1st payment: 37.7%, 2nd: 34.6%, 3rd: 31.6%. Avg revenue: $768/contract.

Group 2 (>10% deposit): 6,702 contracts, avg package $3,366, avg deposit $668 (19.8%). Collection rate of what's due: 47.1%. 1st payment: 58.9%, 2nd: 51.3%, 3rd: 47.2%. Avg revenue: $1,339/contract.

Group 2 collects better. When measured proportionally (only counting installments that have fallen due), Group 2 collects at 47.1% vs Group 1's 35.1%. Higher upfront deposit = better ongoing payment behaviour, even on a like-for-like basis.

Generated November 17, 2026 • CRM Daily Sales + Square Recurring Invoices • Studio 1 Automation