A briefing for the directors. Measured 5 November 2026. Financed sales only (paid in full left out), with the card each customer paid with in the studio. “App-bank” means Chime (The Bancorp Bank or Stride Bank), Cash App (Sutton Bank), Varo, Green Dot and Pathward. A card number only names the bank, so read “Chime” as almost certainly Chime.
The difference is real and large. At weekends an app-bank sale has brought in $853; a sale on any other card $1,728. Four in ten app-bank customers never pay a single instalment, against one in six. They put less down and buy smaller packages.
But a weekend ban would not capture that money, for three reasons.
1. Weekends are not selling out. Settled weekend days fill around 82–90% of the slots on offer (September 2026, /diary-fill). A slot freed by turning a Chime customer away is usually left empty, not taken by a better payer. The $875 gap is only gained on a weekend that would otherwise turn someone away. On any other weekend, moving them loses their $853 unless they rebook a weekday, and on a weekday they are worth less ($717).
2. You cannot see the card when they book. The booking deposit is usually paid on a different card from the one used in the studio. Of the people who booked on an app-bank card, only 43% paid on one in the studio, so a booking rule would move 121 good payers for every 91 it catches, and miss most of the app-bank customers who booked on another card.
3. They are better customers at weekends than on weekdays. Weekend app-bank sales are worth $853 and 40% never pay; weekday ones $717 and 48% never pay. The rule pushes them towards the days they pay worst.
Where the money actually is: the risk shows up at the moment the finance is set up, and that is the moment the card is known for certain. An app-bank customer who put down 25% or more has been worth $1,168; one who put down under 15%, $621, with 54% never paying. Options to trial, each with a control group: a higher minimum deposit when the plan is on an app-bank card, or asking for the plan to go on a bank debit or credit card. The deposit is chosen by the customer, so the 25%+ group are partly different people; forcing a bigger deposit will lose some sales and will not automatically earn $1,168. That is why it needs a trial, not a policy.
Sales from 15 Sep 2024 to 31 Oct 2025, so every one has had at least 12 months to pay. Worth = deposit on the day + everything collected on the plan since (to 5 Nov 2026). Some plans are still paying, so these creep up slightly.
| Card | Day | Sales | Deposit | Collected since | Worth to date | Never paid an instalment |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chime | Weekend | 179 | $370 | $427 | $797 | 37% |
| Cash App | Weekend | 185 | $346 | $430 | $776 | 46% |
| All app-bank cards | Weekend | 484 | $375 | $478 | $853 | 40% |
| All other cards | Weekend | 2,866 | $558 | $1,170 | $1,728 | 16% |
| Chime | Weekday | 273 | $340 | $362 | $702 | 46% |
| Cash App | Weekday | 411 | $348 | $316 | $664 | 50% |
| All app-bank cards | Weekday | 908 | $358 | $359 | $717 | 48% |
| All other cards | Weekday | 4,883 | $561 | $1,104 | $1,665 | 19% |
Financed sales May–Oct 2026. Up front = booking deposit plus cash and card on the order. The three bands add to 100% of each row (rounding aside).
| Card | Who | Sales | Avg up front | % of package | Under 15% down | 15–25% down | 25%+ down |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chime | Adults | 112 | $339 | 14.6% | 57% | 31% | 12% |
| Cash App | Adults | 162 | $368 | 15.5% | 52% | 36% | 11% |
| All app-bank cards | Adults | 351 | $378 | 16.0% | 52% | 34% | 13% |
| All other cards | Adults | 1,979 | $560 | 20.2% | 44% | 28% | 28% |
| Chime | Kids | 48 | $327 | 13.0% | 69% | 25% | 6% |
| Cash App | Kids | 60 | $507 | 17.9% | 47% | 40% | 13% |
| All app-bank cards | Kids | 141 | $452 | 16.3% | 59% | 30% | 11% |
| All other cards | Kids | 938 | $665 | 21.7% | 40% | 27% | 33% |
Same sales as section 1, split by the deposit as a share of the package. An app-bank customer with 25%+ down is worth about the same as an ordinary-card customer with under 15% down.
| Deposit | App-bank sales | App-bank worth | App-bank never paid | Other-card sales | Other-card worth | Other-card never paid |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Under 15% down | 658 | $621 | 54% | 2,495 | $1,222 | 27% |
| 15–25% down | 563 | $809 | 42% | 3,226 | $1,729 | 17% |
| 25% or more down | 171 | $1,168 | 23% | 2,028 | $2,198 | 8% |
Bookings that reached the studio May–Oct 2026, by the first card the person paid with (mostly the $50 booking deposit). Only 19 app-bank no-sales, so a few either way moves the rate. Three in four no-sales never paid by card at all.
| Card | Bookings | No-sales |
|---|---|---|
| Chime | 237 | 6 2.5% |
| Cash App | 311 | 4 1.3% |
| Other app banks | 251 | 9 3.6% |
| All app-bank cards | 799 | 19 2.4% |
| All other cards | 5,796 | 182 3.1% |
Bookings where we saw both a booking-deposit card and the card paid in the studio, May–Oct 2026. Often a parent, partner or friend pays the booking deposit.
| Booking deposit paid on | Paid in studio on an app-bank card | Paid in studio on another card | Bookings |
|---|---|---|---|
| Booked on an app-bank card | 91 43% | 121 57% | 212 |
| Booked on another card | 122 7% | 1670 93% | 1,792 |