Share:

July 2026 — Why Recurring Payments Fail

All six Square accounts · Boston, Texas, New York, Florida, Chicago, Nashville · Data pulled live from Square, full pagination verified

The headline

Across every studio, 60% of automatic recurring charge attempts failed in July. This is not a collections effort problem — the money is being asked for and the card is saying no before anyone picks up a phone.

60%
of charge attempts FAILED
(8,438 of 14,168)
6,120
missed payments in July
across 5,914 people
$1,218,585
value of July's
missed payments
$6,563,746
actually owed by those
people once arrears count
Chasing "what's due" understates the problem 5.4×. July's misses are worth $1,218,584.97. The same people are already carrying $5,345,160.73 of older unpaid invoices behind them. The real exposure is $6,563,745.70.

By account

AccountMissesPeopleDueTotal exposureFail rateNever paid
Texas 1,881 1,835 $390,418.13 $2,314,478.74 62.5% 894 48%
New York 1,388 1,344 $266,704.94 $1,681,567.12 63.1% 534 38%
Florida 917 884 $202,083.74 $884,783.39 55% 425 46%
Nashville 741 711 $130,949.09 $663,241.05 58.9% 283 38%
Boston 562 535 $105,592.40 $555,217.56 56% 192 34%
Chicago 631 605 $122,836.67 $464,457.84 56.4% 315 50%
TOTAL6,1205,914$1,218,584.97$6,563,745.7059.6%2643

Who these people are

Every missed payment was checked against that customer's full invoice history — every payment they have ever been asked for, and whether they paid it.

71%
are already 3+ payments
behind (4,348 of 6,120)
43%
have never paid us a single
invoice, ever (2,643)
16%
are a genuine first miss
(976)
A "friendly reminder" is the wrong tool for most of this book. Only 16% of July's misses are someone slipping for the first time. The rest are people we have already chased repeatedly, or who have never paid us anything at all.

Square tells us why the card said no

Every failed attempt returns a decline reason from the issuing bank, so people can be sorted into the right conversation on the day it fails — before anyone replies to us.

ReasonCountValueWhat it means
TRANSACTION_LIMIT1,999$389,286.20Amount too high / credit limit reached. Money.
GENERIC_DECLINE1,752$371,774.50Bank will not say why. Genuine unknown.
No attempt made955$186,080.12No card held for them — nothing was ever charged.
CARDHOLDER_INSUFFICIENT_PERMISSIONS544$100,290.50Card restricted by the issuer.
INSUFFICIENT_FUNDS441$83,552.05No money in the account. Money.
INVALID_ACCOUNT175$35,222.08Bank cannot find the account. Card dead or closed.
CARD_EXPIRED102$19,125.75Card past its expiry date.
PAN_FAILURE92$19,763.63Card number invalid.
ISSUER_INSTALLMENT_ERROR58$12,832.64Issuer cannot process an instalment on this card.
CVV_FAILURE1$300.00Security code did not match.
INSUFFICIENT_PERMISSIONS1$357.50—
TOTAL6,120$1,218,584.97

The conversations this creates

BucketPeopleValueThe opening message
MONEY2,440$472,838.25Skip the card question. Open with the bad-month framing and offer a smaller instalment.
UNKNOWN1,752$371,774.50No reason given. Use the either/or message and let them self-sort.
NO CARD ON FILE955$186,080.12Never tell these people a payment was declined — it never happened. Ask them to set up payment.
CARD RESTRICTED603$113,480.64Issuer has blocked this card for this use. They need a different card.
ADMIN195$39,189.38Bad card details. Quick correction, no money conversation.
DEAD CARD175$35,222.08Account closed — they need to add a new card, not fix an expiry. No discount conversation.
Why this is worth doing. 3,680 of 6,120 misses (60%) get a message that never mentions discounts, hardship or payment plans — because their problem isn't money, it's a broken card or no card at all. Today they all get the same chase.

Account by account

Texas 62.5% fail rate

Misses 1,881 People 1,835 Due $390,418.13 Exposure $2,314,478.74 3+ behind 73% Never paid 48%
MONEY 736UNKNOWN 576NO CARD ON FILE 253CARD RESTRICTED 208ADMIN 64DEAD CARD 44
TRANSACTION_LIMIT 626GENERIC_DECLINE 576(no attempt) 253CARDHOLDER_INSUFFICIENT_PERMISSIONS 192INSUFFICIENT_FUNDS 110INVALID_ACCOUNT 44PAN_FAILURE 32CARD_EXPIRED 32ISSUER_INSTALLMENT_ERROR 16

New York 63.1% fail rate

Misses 1,388 People 1,344 Due $266,704.94 Exposure $1,681,567.12 3+ behind 78% Never paid 38%
MONEY 520UNKNOWN 412NO CARD ON FILE 261CARD RESTRICTED 104ADMIN 58DEAD CARD 33
TRANSACTION_LIMIT 419GENERIC_DECLINE 412(no attempt) 261INSUFFICIENT_FUNDS 101CARDHOLDER_INSUFFICIENT_PERMISSIONS 92INVALID_ACCOUNT 33PAN_FAILURE 30CARD_EXPIRED 27ISSUER_INSTALLMENT_ERROR 12CVV_FAILURE 1

Florida 55% fail rate

Misses 917 People 884 Due $202,083.74 Exposure $884,783.39 3+ behind 59% Never paid 46%
MONEY 378UNKNOWN 262NO CARD ON FILE 147CARD RESTRICTED 91ADMIN 28DEAD CARD 11
TRANSACTION_LIMIT 332GENERIC_DECLINE 262(no attempt) 147CARDHOLDER_INSUFFICIENT_PERMISSIONS 73INSUFFICIENT_FUNDS 46ISSUER_INSTALLMENT_ERROR 18CARD_EXPIRED 15PAN_FAILURE 13INVALID_ACCOUNT 11

Nashville 58.9% fail rate

Misses 741 People 711 Due $130,949.09 Exposure $663,241.05 3+ behind 69% Never paid 38%
MONEY 310UNKNOWN 201NO CARD ON FILE 107CARD RESTRICTED 75DEAD CARD 32ADMIN 16
TRANSACTION_LIMIT 238GENERIC_DECLINE 201(no attempt) 107INSUFFICIENT_FUNDS 72CARDHOLDER_INSUFFICIENT_PERMISSIONS 71INVALID_ACCOUNT 32CARD_EXPIRED 12PAN_FAILURE 4ISSUER_INSTALLMENT_ERROR 3INSUFFICIENT_PERMISSIONS 1

Boston 56% fail rate

Misses 562 People 535 Due $105,592.40 Exposure $555,217.56 3+ behind 76% Never paid 34%
MONEY 225UNKNOWN 142NO CARD ON FILE 92CARD RESTRICTED 49DEAD CARD 38ADMIN 16
TRANSACTION_LIMIT 158GENERIC_DECLINE 142(no attempt) 92INSUFFICIENT_FUNDS 67CARDHOLDER_INSUFFICIENT_PERMISSIONS 42INVALID_ACCOUNT 38PAN_FAILURE 8CARD_EXPIRED 8ISSUER_INSTALLMENT_ERROR 7

Chicago 56.4% fail rate

Misses 631 People 605 Due $122,836.67 Exposure $464,457.84 3+ behind 65% Never paid 50%
MONEY 271UNKNOWN 159NO CARD ON FILE 95CARD RESTRICTED 76DEAD CARD 17ADMIN 13
TRANSACTION_LIMIT 226GENERIC_DECLINE 159(no attempt) 95CARDHOLDER_INSUFFICIENT_PERMISSIONS 74INSUFFICIENT_FUNDS 45INVALID_ACCOUNT 17CARD_EXPIRED 8PAN_FAILURE 5ISSUER_INSTALLMENT_ERROR 2

The data problem to fix first

The daily missed-payments report can't drive this process yet. It labels each miss using the sequence number printed on the invoice — invoice 12 of a plan becomes "12th miss" — which is not the same thing at all.

AccountRows checkedLabel correctAccuracy
Texas1,78773141%
New York1,30644834%
Florida84134741%
Nashville69323734%
Boston52716231%
Chicago57224142%
TOTAL5,7262,16638%
The escalation ladder is keyed off a number that is wrong 62% of the time. It is wrong in both directions — first-time missers get chased like chronic debtors, and people ten payments behind get a gentle nudge. The report also reads only the first 6,000 invoices per account; Boston alone holds 32,343, so each customer's history is truncated before the label is even calculated.

Both are one change to a single script. Once fixed, the daily report can carry the true miss number and the decline reason side by side, and the team gets a routed call list each morning instead of a flat chase list.

Prepared 2026-08-03. Figures pulled live from the Square Invoices and Payments APIs across all six accounts, full pagination verified on every pull (404,925 invoices read). Missed payments cover due dates 1–31 July 2026; decline reasons cover charge attempts 25 June – 4 August 2026, joined to invoices by order ID where possible (96% exact, remainder matched on customer within 12 days of the due date).

Method: Cancelled invoices are excluded from both misses and exposure — a cancelled plan is not money owed. Exposure is each customer's total unpaid balance counted once, not re-added per missed invoice. Applying these two rules removed $1.9M of overstatement that a naive count produces. Customer names and contact details deliberately excluded from this summary.